
New South Wales has stopped work towards a full business case for a pipeline from Keepit Dam to Tamworth. It will first seek approvals to use an existing drought pipeline, redirecting near-term effort from new construction to operating readiness.
New South Wales asked for a route to improve Tamworth’s drought security. Its preliminary appraisal identified a pipeline from Keepit Dam to the city’s Calala treatment plant as the preferred major project. On November 5, the water minister stopped work towards the full business case for the Keepit pipeline. The government instead asked WaterNSW to prioritize approvals for future operation of the existing Chaffey pipeline. The sequence matters: one decision closes the next appraisal stage for a new asset, while the other begins work on permission to use an asset already in the ground.
What the Business Case Ranked
The preliminary business case compared four major options. One would store Peel River water away from the river channel. A second would transfer water from the Manning catchment to Chaffey Dam. The two others would bring water from Keepit Dam or Split Rock Dam to Calala. The distinction is where each option finds water or holds it until it is needed. Storage can save water from periods of higher flows for use later. A connection from another dam can let the utility draw on a different source when the usual supply is under pressure, subject to how much water is available there and who can use it.
The appraisal found that the Keepit and Split Rock pipelines were the more affordable options it assessed and had the lowest estimated effects on residential bills. Those are comparisons within the set of major projects, using funding assumptions. The appraisal had yet to test customers’ willingness and ability to pay for different service levels. Keepit’s preferred ranking did not establish an affordable bill or answer how competing users would be affected in a dry year.
Why the State Stopped at Appraisal
The state estimated that taking the project to construction readiness would cost A$13.6 million, including the full business case. It put the likely cost of the finished project above A$340 million. Even if the full business case led to an investment decision, the project would take years to prepare and build. It could therefore offer longer-term protection while leaving the city’s near-term response to drought dependent on the assets it already had.
Downstream communities and water users also objected. The government cited those concerns alongside cost when it declined to proceed. A pipeline could give Tamworth a physical connection to Keepit, but it would also put another supply claim on a dam that other users depend on. The announcement gives a reason for the decision; it does not quantify how much water those users would have lost under different drought or allocation rules.
Why an Existing Pipe Still Needs Approval
The Chaffey pipeline was built during the previous drought and operated temporarily in 2020. WaterNSW describes its purpose as delivering water through a pipe instead of relying on its passage down the Peel River, where some water can be lost to evaporation and infiltration. The temporary operating arrangements ended. Having the pipe in place shortens the list of construction tasks, but it does not settle the conditions under which WaterNSW can use it again.
Approvals will determine when the operator can switch routes and what conditions it must meet. That is consequential for other river users and for the river itself, because diverting water into a pipe changes how supply releases move downstream. The new direction is to seek those approvals. The decision does not say that the pipeline has resumed service or that a particular volume will be available in the next dry spell.
How Smaller Savings Fit the Drought Plan
The state also decided against proceeding with advanced treatment to produce recycled water for industrial users after a separate business case. Meanwhile, it reports that the Calala to Dungowan pipeline, completed in 2023, is helping save up to 2.2 megaliters a day. It attributes a further 115 megaliters in annual savings to active leak detection. A maximum daily saving and a reported annual saving describe different things; neither is a new stored reserve.
Tamworth can reduce losses now while WaterNSW works out the operating conditions for Chaffey. Each step makes a different contribution. Less leakage reduces demand on supplies already available, while an approved pipeline gives the operator another way to deliver water during a drought. The sequence makes the next decision concrete: settle when that existing route can be used and what it can reliably supply before relying on it in a drought plan.
Take-Out
A preferred construction option can lose to an existing asset if the immediate problem is drought readiness. Tamworth’s next milestone is an operating approval for the Chaffey pipeline, which still needs water and acceptable operating conditions.
Questions and answers
What readers should know
- What did the minister stop?
- The minister instructed officials to stop work towards a full business case for the Keepit Dam pipeline.
- Did the preliminary appraisal reject Keepit?
- No. It ranked Keepit as the preferred major infrastructure option among those examined.
- Why did the state decline to proceed?
- It cited costs and objections from downstream communities and water users. The project would also take years.
- What is the next priority?
- WaterNSW has been asked to pursue approvals for future operation of the existing Chaffey pipeline.
- Is the Chaffey pipeline already back in service?
- The November direction is about obtaining approvals. It does not announce renewed operation.
Stay in the loop
Keep Mark and Focus in view
Hear about future publications, announcements, and relevant updates from Mark and Focus.