Mark and Focus analysis

Center-Running Bus Lanes Change Flatbush Avenue

Read the analysis
Brooklyn Bridge beside the Lower Manhattan skyline
The Brooklyn Bridge spans the East River in New York City. scratsmacker / Pixabay · https://pixabay.com/service/license-summary/

New York City has completed a Flatbush Avenue redesign with 1.9 miles of protected center-running bus lanes and six boarding islands. The project changes how buses, pedestrians and deliveries share a busy Brooklyn corridor.

A bus could crawl at about four miles per hour on Flatbush Avenue before the redesign. The street carries some of Brooklyn’s busiest bus routes, yet a rider sitting through a short trip could spend much of it waiting in the same traffic as everyone else. On November 17, New York City announced that construction was complete on 1.9 miles of protected center-running bus lanes, with six concrete boarding islands. Building the lanes solves one part of the problem. How the rest of the street works around them will determine what riders gain from the investment.

Why the Bus Lanes Moved Away from the Curb

Along a commercial street, the curb has several jobs. Shop deliveries need a place to stop, passengers get out of cars and parked vehicles move in and out of spaces. Buses using the same edge of the road can lose time even when a lane is reserved for them. They may need to wait behind a stopped vehicle, pull out and merge back, or try to reach the sidewalk through traffic.

Moving buses to the center gives them a relatively clear path between stops. Physical barriers help preserve that space when traffic builds. The design does take room from general traffic. The Department of Transportation’s plans show one general travel lane in each direction between Atlantic Avenue and Grand Army Plaza, with more through lanes farther north. That variation reflects a decision about how the available width is divided block by block.

The New Stop Begins at the Sidewalk

A bus that runs in the middle of the street needs a safe place for passengers to get on. The six concrete islands give riders a place to wait next to the bus lane, with shelters and seating. To get there, however, riders have to reach the island from the sidewalk. Crossing design and signals become part of the trip. A well-protected lane offers little benefit to a rider who needs another signal cycle just to reach the stop, or who finds the route from the curb hard to navigate.

The city paired the islands with curb extensions and signal changes, including accessible pedestrian signals and countdowns. It reported about 29,000 square feet of new pedestrian space from the islands and extensions together. Some islands also create an intermediate place to pause during a crossing. The value of that space will vary with the intersection layout and the way turning traffic is managed.

Loading and Turning Still Need Room

The city retained curb access through dedicated loading zones and revised parking rules. That matters to bus operations because shifting vehicles away from the transit lane can simply move a conflict to an intersection. If a truck cannot reach a loading bay or complete a turn, it can hold up the general lane. A queue can then reach back into a crossing or block turning traffic that has to pass through the bus lane.

Flatbush Avenue’s design briefing shows how the city addressed some of those conflicts. It proposed changes to the direction of a nearby stretch of Pacific Street and a restriction on longer vehicles making one turn at Bergen Street. These are small decisions on a corridor map, with real consequences for how an operator routes a delivery. Construction also had to preserve trips while moving the route toward its permanent layout. The department planned to rebuild one side at a time, with temporary stops, markings and reroutes before the final street layout went in.

What Completion Lets the City Measure

The project gives New York a design in operation ahead of its goal of bus rapid transit on Flatbush Avenue by 2030. It also gives the city and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority different things to check. Street staff can observe how intersections, loading bays and crossings work under pressure. The transit operator can compare running times and the spread between an ordinary trip and a slow one. Averages alone can miss whether the worst delays are concentrated at particular turns or at the ends of the protected section.

The city’s completion announcement gives the historical speed and identifies what opened. It does not give a corridor-wide, measured travel-time result after opening. The more telling comparison will follow riders through and beyond the new lanes, including the time they spend reaching a stop and the delay they encounter when the dedicated lane ends. Those observations can shape the next section toward Avenue H before its geometry is fixed.

Take-Out

Putting buses in the center frees them from curbside conflicts. Keeping the improvement through busy periods will depend on how boarding, turns, signals and loading work around the protected lanes.

Questions and answers

What readers should know

Where are the new bus lanes?
They are on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn. The project completed in November adds 1.9 miles of protected lanes in the middle of the street.
Why are the lanes in the center?
Buses can travel away from parking and loading activity at the curb. Physical protection helps preserve a path through congestion.
How do passengers board?
Six concrete islands place waiting passengers beside the center-running lanes. People get to the islands from the sidewalk at designated crossings.
What changed for deliveries?
There are dedicated loading zones and revised metered parking rules. Trucks and passenger vehicles share curb space according to the applicable signs.
Is the full rapid transit project open?
The redesigned section is open. New York City treats it as a first step toward bus rapid transit on the corridor by 2030.

Further analysis

More from this desk